« Mix Your Own Sopranos Ending | Main | The Favicons of Music 2.0 »

Sonific: More Choice, but Major Issues Remain

sonific_logo.jpgSonific allows users to select a song from their catalog and add it to any website, blog or social network profile. I have been aware for them for some time but avoided using the service because their catalog was so small and I had a very difficult time finding anything I would want to hear. Thankfully, Sonific has added another 100,000 tracks with an emphasis on Jazz and Blues. They have also announced a new beta service that allows artists and labels to upload their own content for use within the Sonific network.

At least they have some music I like now. However the service still sufferers from a few major problems. Now that the catalog is growing, they need to seriously work on their search and browse functionality. Genres are represented using a tag cloud which doesn’t make much sense as users can’t tag songs. It’s also a waste of space since there are only about 12 genres to choose from. When selecting a genre from their tag cloud, you get a list of subgenres and featured artists. However, many times a subgenre will return no results. Suggestion: Hide subgenres if you don’t have any content in them. They could also use a genre-specific page that contains charts of top songs, top artists, etc.

sonific_genres.jpg

There’s no way to currently just see a list of artists in a genre without scrolling through a very large set of song-based search results. Suggestion: provide a way to quickly browse artists outside the context of a song. iTunes’ 4-pane browse feature does this well and LaLa has extended it to their new service. And last but not least, the fact that I need to click the “Find Songspots” tab every time i want to find something is needlessly annoying. Suggestion: provide a persistent search box on every page.

Setting up a Songspot for your site is pretty straightforward and they support over 42 platforms. Just select the “Use” button on any item you want and configure the widget for your site. My only suggestion here would be for a live preview of the player that dynamically updates as you change your settings. Sonific keeps a record of your songspots and you can always go back and edit ones you have created.

sonific_configure.jpg

My major issue with Sonific is that other services out there (legal issues aside) like imeem, ProjectPlaylist, Finetune and Dizzler allow you to create and share entire playlists of music where Sonfic restricts you to a single song. This may be cool for a “Song of the Day” feature or featuring a specific podcast. However, in the end I don’t know if this model can compete with the ability to share multiple songs via a single widget.



PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (6)

Hello RocketSurgeon, I am the co-founder and CEO of Sonific. Your coverage of our service is very much appreciated, and you are spot-on with your comments. All of this is actually in the oven, both as far as a much better search goes, and as far as offering playlists goes. But I would dare say that we have a lot more tracks that you may like - you just may not know them yet ;). Check out the featured artists in each genre.

However, as far as the legal issues go, I have to disagree with you: this is NOT something you can just 'leave aside'. Immeem has been sued for prividing playlists on demand without a license (apparently), finetune does seem to have some licenses but I have no idea how they can afford the ones they may have, given the current prices per streams that the major labels want(ed) ;). Sonific has a license for every single track we offer, and getting that done takes time, and is based on opt-ins from the labels. That's just the way the cookie crumbles, right now.

But thanks for your feedback - it's very much appreciated.
Gerd

06.14.2007 | Unregistered CommenterGerd Leonhard

What about the "water"?

06.14.2007 | Unregistered CommenterJuliano Polimeno

Gerd, thanks for the added insight into your model. I'm glad to see you are being diligent with the licensing. Do you need a seperate license (in addition to DMCA compliance) to allow users to create playlists or are you just trying to keep it simple for the time being until there is enough critical mass/revenue to allow for that feature?

06.16.2007 | Registered CommenterJadam Kahn

Jadam, all pur licenses are done via direct deals with the rights holders so the DMCA compliance is not an issue with us; we can present the music in any way we like. The playlist creation tool is in the oven; this has simply been a question of R&D timing --- but in any case, we do have a few surprises wrapped in that, too -- stay tuned. Also, check out www.sonific.net where artists and labels can submit their own music. Cheers, Gerd

PS: on the music like water comment: indeed that is where we are going... watch this space.

06.20.2007 | Unregistered CommenterGerd Leonhard

Thanks for the clarification. I look forward to seeing your upcoming enhancements.

06.20.2007 | Registered CommenterJadam Kahn

Just wanted to share with you that Sonific now DOES have playlists - we launched this 2 days ago. Up to 25 tracks, any order, full-length, no limits, over 200.000 songs to chose from. Check out our blog at www.songspotting.com --- and widgetize!

08.9.2007 | Unregistered CommenterGerd Leonhard

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>